We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.

Updated November 2026 · Independent comparison for U.S. federal and military retirees
If you have retirement savings in the Thrift Savings Plan (TSP), you may be considering whether to transfer some eligible funds to a self-directed IRA that holds physical gold. The most important question is not simply which dealer sells gold. It is whether a rollover makes sense for your circumstances, and how the full costs and risks compare with keeping your current TSP investments.
Quick answer: should you roll over your TSP to a Gold IRA?
Not automatically. Some TSP distributions are eligible for direct rollover into an IRA, but not all payments qualify. An IRA holding physical precious metals adds custodian, depository and transaction costs and exposure to metal prices. The TSP may offer simpler investment choices and favorable fees. Verify your options before acting.
The four providers below are comparison candidates, not an independently established ranking of investment returns. We reviewed available published terms and education materials; we did not complete mystery-shopper rollovers or obtain binding quotes. Aurum Harbor has a Birch Gold Group affiliate relationship but has not confirmed equivalent relationships with the other companies.
Gold IRA companies at a glance
| Provider | Published minimum | Published annual fees (illustrative) |
|---|---|---|
| Birch Gold Group | $5,000 | $235 in a sample custodian/depository arrangement |
| Augusta Precious Metals | $50,000 standard initial purchase | $235 after a $285 first year (standard schedule) |
| Goldco | Generally $25,000 | Approximately $225 in its published example |
| Noble Gold Investments | $20,000 | Request written confirmation; published fee examples vary |
Minimums, promotional terms and costs can change. Even a quoted $235 annual storage and custody charge is not the total economic cost if metal purchase premiums and resale spreads are substantial. Request the exact total in writing.
How we compared these Gold IRA providers
For former federal employees, relevant comparison points are published minimums, the provider’s explanations of custodian and depository roles, account and storage expenses, clarity of metal purchase pricing and buyback bids, and the ability to coordinate an eligible rollover. We did not measure portfolio performance, customer satisfaction in a representative sample, or rollover completion times. A lower stated annual charge alone cannot determine the best provider.
1. Birch Gold Group: detailed published example of account costs
Birch Gold Group helps customers explore IRS-eligible physical precious metals purchased through a self-directed IRA. A custodian manages the IRA administration and a separate depository stores the metals. Birch’s published illustrative arrangement includes a $50 setup charge and a $30 wire charge, plus annual custodian fees of $125 and storage/insurance costs of $110. Its published terms describe first-year fee relief on eligible larger transactions, which should be verified.
Why compare it: clear examples of third-party custodial and storage charges, and an educational process for evaluating metals. Watch for: total metal purchase premiums, resale bids, account-specific custodian charges and your own suitability for a physical-metal IRA.
Our deeper analysis: Birch Gold Group Gold IRA Review: Fees, Rollover Process and Risks.
2. Augusta Precious Metals: higher standard initial purchase
Augusta publishes an illustrative standard account schedule of $285 in the first year and $235 annually after that, before the cost of metals and any purchase-to-buyback spread. It states a standard initial purchase requirement of $50,000. For retirees considering a small physical-metal allocation, that threshold may be a meaningful constraint.
Why compare it: published fee schedule and an emphasis on discussing the prices of specific metals. Watch for: the minimum, current promotion eligibility and whether the written buyback indication is attractive for the exact coins or bars being purchased.

3. Goldco: an alternative with published ranges
Goldco offers gold IRA arrangements using outside custodians and depositories. Its cost explanation describes a general $25,000 minimum and about $225 in annual fees, with roughly $275–$325 in a representative first year. The amounts may differ by account, custodian, storage selection and metals purchased.
Why compare it: another provider to quote for a medium-sized contemplated metals allocation. Watch for: what the fee range includes, whether storage is segregated and the exact difference between the dealer’s sale and repurchase price.
4. Noble Gold Investments: confirm the exact storage price
Noble Gold’s Gold IRA materials describe a $20,000 minimum investment and separate setup, account-maintenance and insured-storage costs. Its published materials have referenced different annual totals across pages, so a dated written fee sheet is essential before comparing the offer with others.
Why compare it: a published starting minimum between Birch Gold and Goldco. Watch for: which custodian and depository apply, whether storage is segregated and all transaction and buyback charges.
TSP-to-Gold IRA rollover rules for retired federal employees
The IRS allows certain eligible rollover distributions from the TSP to be paid directly to an IRA. However, required minimum distributions, hardship payments and certain long-term installment arrangements are generally not eligible. When an eligible taxable distribution is paid directly to the participant instead, mandatory withholding can apply. Traditional and Roth balances require different treatment.
- Confirm TSP eligibility first: ask the plan whether the amount you intend to move qualifies and which distribution choices are available.
- Keep the tax treatment straight: review whether funds are traditional, Roth or mixed and what type of receiving account is appropriate.
- Compare keeping TSP assets: evaluate investment choice, ongoing expenses, simplicity, liquidity and any protections you may lose.
- Explore partial options: an eligible partial rollover may be possible; do not assume you need to move the whole account.
- Coordinate carefully: if moving funds is appropriate, work with the TSP and the receiving custodian on the exact approved process.
For authoritative rules, see IRS Publication 721 and the IRS retirement-plan rollover guidance. A dealer is not a substitute for tax advice or official plan eligibility information.
Expenses a fee chart cannot fully capture
- Dealer spread: the difference between the purchase price and the bid to buy back the metal.
- Eligibility: not every gold coin or bar is permitted in an IRA. Personal storage can create serious tax problems.
- Liquidity: metals might need to be sold or distributed to meet cash or required-distribution needs.
- Market risk: gold and silver can fall in price and do not pay dividends or interest.
- Opportunity cost: giving up low-cost TSP options may raise total expenses or change diversification.
For illustration only, $235 of recurring fees is 2.35% of a $10,000 account versus 0.235% of a $100,000 account, before spreads and all other costs. A flat-fee IRA may therefore be disproportionately expensive for a small precious-metals allocation.

Seven questions to ask before choosing
- What is the complete first-year and five-year expense, including setup, custodian, storage, insurance and closing fees?
- What exact metals would I purchase, and what are the full purchase prices and same-day buyback bids?
- Who is the legal IRA custodian and which facility stores the assets?
- Are there fees for wire transfers, liquidation, delivery or account transfer?
- Which parts of any advertised promotion are in writing, and who qualifies?
- How would required minimum distributions or emergency liquidity be handled?
- What advantages or safeguards would I give up if I transferred eligible funds out of the TSP?
Our conclusion
There is no universally best Gold IRA company for retired federal employees. Birch Gold, Augusta, Goldco and Noble Gold differ in published minimums and fee arrangements, but actual outcomes depend on the assets purchased, the quote and whether moving money from TSP is appropriate. Start with the official TSP and IRS eligibility rules and compare written proposals before committing retirement savings.
If you want to explore Birch Gold Group’s offering, request its current Gold IRA information and fee details. Asking for information does not itself require a rollover or a purchase.
Sources and editorial notes
- IRS Publication 721: Civil Service Retirement Benefits.
- IRS: Retirement-plan rollovers.
- Birch Gold Group: Prices and fees.
- Augusta Precious Metals: IRA FAQ.
- Goldco: Gold IRA costs.
- Noble Gold Investments: Gold IRA page.
Educational information only; not personalized financial, legal or tax advice. Provider figures are self-reported and subject to change. Aurum Harbor has an affiliate relationship with Birch Gold Group and may earn compensation on qualified referrals; this does not establish it as superior to the other providers.